Menu of Second Avenue Pizza in Sandpoint, Idaho, USA

Menu Overview

Second Avenue Pizza in Sandpoint, ID, stands out as a genuine hometown gem for pizza lovers and comfort food seekers alike. Nestled on S 2nd Ave, this spot marries tradition with bold, fresh flavors that resonate deeply with locals and visitors. The menu is a harmonious blend of inventive house specialties and classic staples, showcasing a clear passion for quality and variety.

The spotlight shines brightly on their unique specialty pizzas such as the Jukebox Special, a robust medley of pepperoni, salami, spicy Italian sausage, mushrooms, olives, and onions. This pie is a carnivore’s dream and rightfully earns rave reviews for its hearty, perfectly balanced toppings atop that satisfyingly crisp crust. Equally notable is the Carolyn Special, a delightful calzone featuring fresh spinach, onions, and olives, providing a savory, comforting option that’s both hearty and fresh. For those craving creative flavor twists, the Mexican Pizza and Taco Pizza bring bold, spicy elements that elevate the classic pizza experience.

Vegetable lovers will appreciate the Schweitzer Ski Flake pizza, a vibrant composition of fresh spinach, tomatoes, feta, garlic, mushrooms, and black olives, all layered generously with asiago cheese. This offering captures a balance of earthiness and brightness, demonstrating Second Avenue’s skill in crafting pizzas that go beyond ordinary toppings. The Fresh Garde Special follows suit with a garden festival of onions, broccoli, olives, bell peppers, and tomatoes, fresh and crisp.

Sandwich options like the Italian Meatball Sub and Hot Pastrami & Sauerkraut deliver the same quality and care reflected in the pizzas, showing Second Avenue’s respect for hearty, well-flavored handhelds. Their Italian Focaccia, praised by repeat diners, offers a crave-worthy texture and flavor that rounds out the menu well.

Salads such as the Chicken Caesar and the Chef Salad provide refreshing, crunchy contrasts to the pizza-heavy menu, making this a well-rounded destination for any group.

What truly elevates Second Avenue Pizza is its ability to cater to diverse dietary needs without compromising taste. Gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese options are rare finds done right here. These accommodations mean more food lovers can indulge in the vibrant, comforting flavors without sacrificing quality.

Customers frequently echo sentiments of nostalgia and satisfaction. Samantha Hoffman’s praise for the You Name It Combo reflects the pizza’s generous nature, combining an array of toppings that feel both bountiful and thoughtfully assembled. The enduring appeal, as noted by long-time regulars like Heather Cowan and Kevin Ferrell, lies in consistently delivering massive, flavorful pizzas that satisfy every time, turning casual diners into loyal patrons.

The atmosphere and staff also play a key role in creating a welcoming experience. Mal’s reflection on the warm, comforting vibe and attentive service highlights a strong community connection. It’s this blend of exceptional food and genuine hospitality that cements Second Avenue Pizza as a Sandpoint institution.

In summary, Second Avenue Pizza offers an impressive menu highlighted by inventive specialty pizzas, quality sandwiches, and accommodating options for various dietary preferences. Each dish is thoughtfully crafted with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that stick in your memory. Whether you’re a meat-lover, vegetable enthusiast, or a seeker of classic comfort food, Second Avenue Pizza delivers authenticity and satisfaction with every bite.